Technology
Who The Machine Says You Are
Algorithmic character, population management, and the philosophers we forgot to invite: On how AI inherited rhetoric’s most dangerous art, and what it means for all of us
There is an ancient exercise, once practiced by students in the rhetorical schools of Greece and Rome, called ethopoeia: the art of character making. Derived from ethos (character) and poiein (to make or create), it trained the young orator to compose speech as if it issued from another person, capturing not merely what that person might say but how they would say it, revealing the texture of their moral and psychological disposition. Lysias, the great Athenian logographer, was its acknowledged master. He wrote courtroom speeches for clients he would never meet in person, yet those speeches were so precisely fitted to the character of the speaker that juries found them credible. The technique depended on intimate knowledge: of the speaker, the audience, the occasion, the entire web of circumstances in which a characterization could land as persuasive rather than false.
Plato, characteristically, regarded ethopoeia with suspicion; he saw in it a species of trickery, a form of mimesis that could deceive an audience into trusting a fabricated persona. Aristotle was more sanguine. He believed every speaker engaged in ethopoeia whether they knew it or not, that the construction of character was simply what happened in the act of public address. For both, however, the crucial point was that ethopoeia involved a human agent making deliberate rhetorical choices in a context they could perceive and to which they were accountable. A logographer who fabricated a persona bore responsibility for the fabrication. The audience, if sufficiently attentive, could detect the artifice.
Now transpose this art to the present. Today, the construction of your character, the rendering of who you are for the purposes of consequential decisions, is performed not by a logographer who has studied you but by computational systems that have ingested your data. Your credit score, your insurance risk profile, your hirability as determined by applicant tracking software, the advertisements you are shown, the news you are permitted to see, the probability that you will commit a future crime (recidivism): All of these are acts of characterization. They are, in a precise and not merely metaphorical sense, acts of ethopoeia. The difference is that no human rhetor stands behind them, no one has composed your character with knowledge of your situation, and no one is accountable for the portrait that results.
What computational rhetoric reveals
The term algorithmic ethopoeia, emerging from recent work in my computational rhetoric at the University of Waterloo, names exactly this phenomenon: the process by which computational systems convert human data into digital characterizations, which are then subjected to algorithmic procedures and made to stand in for the person from whom the data was derived. These characterizations are not neutral; they encode values, make moral judgments, and distribute consequences. They are, in the language of classical rhetoric, ethotic: They pertain to character. And they are being produced at a scale and speed that would have dazzled even Gorgias.



