Human Exceptionalism

Politics

Human Exceptionalism

Benjamin Scott10 min read

Humans have always occupied a strange space among the rest of the Earth’s beings, at least in thought. We have seen ourselves either as beings stretched across two distinct worlds (the physical world and a spiritual realm), or as occupying the chief position of this one world, rivaled in either case only by the gods in whose image we are created, or perhaps, who are created in ours, if we are rivaled at all. This privileged understanding of ourselves acts as the bedrock of our most widespread religious beliefs, the bonds of our moral responsibility to one another, and the face with which we converse with Nature. Performing an analysis of the concept of human exceptionalism is a difficult task, since in order to do so we must attempt to look at human nature, which in itself seems invariably to throw us directly back into the problem we hope to examine. In looking at human nature we will always implicitly assume human exceptionalism or its negative, that is, we are immediately led to conceive of humans as above Nature or utterly within Nature, and there seems to be no way to address the human being in a way which truly gets beyond this binary: that humans are distinct from Nature, or they are not. Since there is no way to get entirely outside of this binary, the best way to treat the subject would be to sometimes assume the one, and at other times assume the other so that the outcome of each assumption can be drawn out and laid beside its counterpart, allowing us to view the poles of the binary in parallel. 

For what purpose do we engage in this investigation? What is at stake in the question? Perhaps, practically speaking, there is no purpose. If we are bound to view ourselves as privileged due to the fact that our perspective is strictly atomic — i.e. composed of individuals who only can see the world from one point, as it were, with a body to maintain, needs to satisfy, desires to negotiate — that is, if we are inevitably subjective and self-interested, then the question here is an idle speculation into the what-ifs of what is most foundational and axiomatic in our thinking. The question would compare to asking, “what if the interior angles of a triangle were not equal to two right angles?” On the other hand, the stakes may be very high, because if we are capable of choosing how we position ourselves in relation to Nature, our choice is either one of indefinitely extending our term as sovereign over the Earth or enacting the ultimate abdication. There are four possibilities, as I see it. The first two assume that we have no choice in the matter: Either we are inevitably bound to rule the Earth (if only in thought) by virtue of our individual and innately self-interested perspective; or we are inevitably going to be overthrown from our privileged position by some external force. This force may come as a result of the discovery of highly superior extra-terrestrials, the creation of a vastly intelligent AI system, or the sheer ineptitude of our rule causing the Kingdom of Earth to shudder and revolt, taking us to the guillotine. The other two possibilities assume that our concepts are created rather than discovered and that we may craft and recraft the concept of the human with an aim to the effects of having this or that conceptualization — being the ruler of Earth, higher than Nature, or subject to Earth, one with Nature. For the sake of rigor, all four possibilities ought to be examined, though the two which presuppose a choice I think are worth the most attention. The two which presuppose no choice bear little utility in their closing of possible action, and the scenario which relies on the appearance of aliens or androids can only, by necessity, be composed of nothing more than speculations. Therefore, if a choice is presupposed to be made between keeping our exceptional status or not, then the consequences of both paths should be made clear, and the binary laid out unclouded by rhetoric arguing definitively for one side or the other. So far as I am aware, there has not yet been such a treatise which neither argues in favor of nor against human exceptionalism — which has not chosen a side and deployed all the force rhetoric can give in swaying the reader to one side or the other.