Return to Bride Kidnapping

Culture

Return to Bride Kidnapping

Mozart, Monoceros, Men ... And a Prophecy

Alice Little26 min read

Gone are your old ideas of life, the old ideas grow dim. Lo and behold, you’re someone’s wife, and you belong to him.

Rodgers & Hammerstein, The Sound of Music

I.

A Brief History of Bride Kidnapping: Signs, Signifiers, & Signified

I recently saw a live production of The Magic Flute in its entirety, which, if you aren’t familiar with Mozart or opera or this opera, is almost too ridiculous to recount but here goes: Pamina is kidnapped from her mother, The Queen of the Night, by Sarastro, her late father’s successor to the (masonic-coded) high-priesthood in the Temple of Isis and Osiris, a holy brotherhood united by the enlightenment ideals of Reason, Nature, and Wisdom. The Queen sends Tamino, a prince, and Papageno, a birdcatcher, armed with a magic flute and a magic glockenspiel respectively, to rescue her daughter from Sarastro. However, almost as soon as they arrive at his temple it becomes clear that The Queen is a destructive force in Pamina’s life, and Sarastro has taken Pamina under his wing, for “Ein Mann muss eure Herzen leiten, / denn ohne ihn pflegt jedes Weib / aus ihrem Wirkungskreis zu schreiten” (A man must guide your heart, / for without him every woman tends / to overstep her natural sphere) (LibrettoArchive). Tamino braves the trials of manhood that Sarastro sets before him, The Queen of the Night is defeated, and Sarastro happily gives Pamina away in marriage to the brave Tamino. Papageno gets his parrot wife, too. 

The story of The Magic Flute is, of course, not native to Mozart and his librettist, but is a Christianized version of an ancient myth: the rape of Proserpina. As with most Greco-Roman myths, there is a common knowledge account which is almost incorrect in its brevity, so I would like to acquaint the reader with some details provided by Ovid:

  1. The trouble starts when Venus, having conquered every other male god with her empire of eros, sets her sights on Pluto as her final frontier. She complains that all the other women in the pantheon hate her, and that she is set on the deflowering of Proserpina.

  2. As Pluto steals away from Earth to Hell with his new bride, a nymph tries to prevent the ravishment, telling how her own husband, who was also struck by Cupid’s arrow, was nice enough to ask before “marrying” her.

  3. Daddy Jove reminds the bereft Ceres that the rape of their daughter was done “not through wickedness, but love” and that it is a good thing to have Pluto as a brother and a son-in-law (Rolfe, 123).

  4. When Jove makes the provision that Proserpina can return from the underworld on the condition that she has not eaten anything, we learn that Proserpina has already eaten seven seeds of a pomegranate, not upon Pluto’s offer, but after seeking the fruit herself.

Now that we have re-established the myth in its entirety, we can extrapolate a few key components. Venus doesn’t prey upon women; it is only men whom she bewitches. Further, she isn’t the one who directly affects them, but her son (boy) with his arrow (phallus). In this mythos, erotic love is imposed upon men by Woman, but only through means that are properly masculine. In this sense, arousal and infatuation are of Woman but only manifest in Man. The maiden is the object of eros but is untouched by its power. In almost all mythological accounts of a woman becoming sexually infatuated with a man, she is far from maiden; Phaedra, the primal nympho, is a married woman, and Dido is no amazonian queen. Indeed, if we broaden our scope to the genre of “first love” or “great love” in the general canon, we will find that it originates in boyhood and not girlhood.

She eats the pomegranate. Just as the Sabine maidens happily submit to their Roman husbands, so too Proserpina submits as wife of Pluto. It is not until after their nuptials that she partakes in satiating her embodied hunger for fruit. Because eros is only first realized in men, the maiden must be stolen for her to realize her hunger. The kidnapping can only transform into a consummated marriage when the maiden of her own accord seeks to satiate her own desire within the coupling. In marriage, kidnapping, or any act whatsoever of expressing love for the beloved, men beckon (or sometimes drag) women into the world of desire.

This literal form of bride kidnapping would, through myth, have continued ad nauseum if it were not for the Word becoming Flesh (John 1:14). Formerly, in the pagan world, spirit was literal and foreign to metaphor, as form preceded language in the theological hierarchy, rendering flesh primary to word. This rudimentary interpretation of phenomena, which hailed the structures of the world to be ontologically and teleologically supreme, allowed for polytheism and fate. Humans were subject to the discordant, harsh whims of nature, both internally and externally. The Hellenic and Roman pantheons, and their spirit-world of myth, understood discrete archetypes of men and women, boys and girls, husbands and wives, to be world-creating gods who wielded eros as a sword to which puny humans bent the knee. But Christ’s coming reversed that hierarchy, and word became primary, and the flesh became subordinate to metaphor. God is now Man and One and Word and, most importantly, Love. Though bride kidnapping is no longer permitted under the New Testament, the psychosexual truths observed in pagan myths like the rape of Proserpina have not disappeared but have been recategorized as sin and thus must be sanctified in marriage. Under Christianity, bride kidnapping and rape must be understood in terms of headship and subordination and mythologized as spiritual rescue. So Paul writes to the Ephesians:

Wives, submit yourselves unto your own husbands, as unto the Lord; for the husband is the head of the wife, even as Christ is the head of the church, and He is the savior of the body. Therefore as the church is subject unto Christ, so let the wives be to their own husbands in every thing. Husbands, love your wives even as Christ also loved the church and gave Himself for it, that He might sanctify and cleanse it with the washing of water by the Word, that He might present it to Himself a glorious church, not having spot or wrinkle or any such thing, but that it should be holy and without blemish. So ought men to love their wives as their own bodies. He that loveth his wife loveth himself.