Technology
Technological Metamorphosis
Botany is genetically one of the oldest natural investigations undertaken by humankind, for what could be more useful than being able to identify which plants are nice to eat, which are poisonous, and which can treat illnesses? It is useful not only to have this power of identification but also to be able to pass it on. Hence, traditions and folklore, and later, treatises and compendiums have passed down our classifications of plants to us from time immemorial.
The beginning of botany as a science in the west is usually attributed to Theophrastus (c. 371 BC – c. 287 BC), who was a close friend to Aristotle, became head of the Academy, and leveraged his mutual friendship to Alexander the Great in order to expand his botanical inquiries beyond the borders of Greece. In his Enquiry into Plants, Book I, Theophrastus focuses on the parts of plants and how they ought to be classified. The classificatory and anatomizing method he deploys here set the stage for botany for many centuries after. He also makes some very interesting remarks on his method that are worth dwelling on for a while:
In considering the distinctive characters of plants and their nature generally one must take into account their parts, their qualities, the ways in which their life originates, and the course which it follows in each case: (conduct and activities we do not find in them, as we do in animals). […]
Now it appears that by a ‘part,’ seeing that it is something which belongs to the plant’s characteristic nature, we mean something which is permanent either absolutely or when once it has appeared (like those parts of animals which remain for a time undeveloped) — permanent, that is, unless it be lost by disease, age or mutilation. […]
But perhaps we should not expect to find in plants a complete correspondence with animals.
(Enquiry into Plants, I. 1-3)
Note how he keeps referring back to animals as a touchstone for anatomizing the plant. No doubt, Theophrastus is drawing off of Aristotle’s Parts of Animals as a guiding method for developing his botany. Animals, to Theophrastus, are analogous to plants. The analogical method really is the basis for nearly all natural enquiries. We must proceed to that which we do not understand from that which we do understand. However, if the object in question turns out to have no distinction at all from that which we know already, the analogical method does not yield much to us.
How exactly does the analogical method work? In order for an analogy to be useful, I posit that there must be a true identity somewhere between the object of study and the analogous object: mere resemblance is not enough. Namely, between the object of study and analogous object there must be a true identity of relations such that the terms between which these relations unfold are perfectly exchangeable. For example, consider a pendulum, a weight on a spring, and an oscillating electrical circuit. These objects have a truly analogous relationship because the relation of periodic motion between the parts is identical between them all, regardless of whether that motion takes place in a ball across an arc, a weight along a line, or electricity through a closed loop. However, it is precisely these differences which give each of the oscillators their own significance. The analogy shows us what is the same while simultaneously giving us a portal into the significance of the object of study by graciously breaking down for us right where we require it to. If two things are entirely different, one cannot be understood by means of the other; on the other hand, if two things are entirely the same, strictly speaking, we do not have two things to consider at all, but only one.
Now, like an animal, a plant develops functional parts, and Theophrastus posits that the parts of a plant must bear some analogical relationship to the parts of an animal. However, it is precisely where the plant is unlike the animal where the significance of the plant itself appears:
We must not assume that in all respects there is a complete correspondence between plants and animals […] for it is a waste of time to take great pains to make comparisons where that is impossible, and in so doing we may lose sight also of our proper subject of enquiry. [...]



